
The U.S. Supreme Court has declined to consider an appeal seeking to reinstate a plea agreement for Khalid Sheikh Mohammed, the accused architect of the September 11, 2001, terrorist attacks. The decision leaves in place a lower court ruling that permitted the cancellation of the agreement, keeping the possibility of capital punishment open as the prosecution moves toward trial.
Mohammed and two co-defendants had asked the nation’s highest court to restore agreements negotiated in 2024. Under the proposed arrangements, the defendants would have pleaded guilty to charges connected to the attacks in exchange for life imprisonment without the possibility of parole, avoiding the death penalty.
The Supreme Court’s refusal to hear the appeals means the agreements will remain revoked unless further legal developments change the course of the proceedings. The decision represents another setback for the defendants in a case that has faced years of litigation, procedural disputes and delays.
Mohammed is accused of playing a central role in planning the September 11 attacks, in which hijacked passenger planes struck the World Trade Center in New York and the Pentagon near Washington, while a fourth aircraft crashed in Pennsylvania after passengers resisted the hijackers. Nearly 3,000 people were killed in the attacks, making the case one of the most consequential terrorism prosecutions in American history.
The plea agreements were negotiated through the military commission system responsible for prosecuting the defendants detained at Guantánamo Bay, Cuba. However, the arrangements encountered opposition from former Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin, who moved to withdraw them after they had been approved in 2024.
Austin maintained that decisions concerning plea agreements in a case of such significance fell within his authority as defense secretary. The defendants subsequently challenged the cancellation, arguing that the agreements should have remained valid once they had been accepted through the military commission process.
A federal appeals court ultimately upheld Austin’s authority to revoke the deals. Mohammed and his co-defendants then sought Supreme Court review, hoping the justices would overturn that decision. By declining to take up the case, the Supreme Court left the lower court’s ruling intact without issuing a new ruling on the underlying legal arguments.
The outcome means prosecutors can continue preparing the case for trial rather than proceed under the terms of the proposed guilty pleas. The military trial has been scheduled for June 2028, although further litigation could affect the timetable.
The prosecution has been complicated by questions about evidence collected during the CIA’s detention and interrogation program following the September 11 attacks. Defense attorneys have challenged the admissibility of statements obtained under coercive conditions, arguing that the treatment of the accused has created significant legal obstacles for the government.
Military judges have considered whether particular statements were made voluntarily and whether prosecutors can rely on them in court. These evidentiary disputes have contributed to the lengthy proceedings and remain important to the eventual trial.
The case has also generated differing views among relatives of the victims. Some families have supported plea agreements as a way to secure admissions of guilt and bring the proceedings closer to a conclusion. Others have opposed arrangements that would remove the possibility of a death sentence, arguing that the severity of the attacks warrants a full trial.
You can watch the video below